But wait, boxing and kickboxing are the same thing. I imagine that we would run into the same issue if we took a combination of Judo, Jiu-Jitsu, or Wrestling. Okay, I'll give that. So let's try something a little more distinct. Take Western Boxing and the Chinese Wing Tsun. These are definitely different:
Start watching at 14:20
Start anywhere ; )
Granted. These are distinct. But wait. If you say to Bob and Weave, you can't plant your feet in a solid stance and simultaneously make contact, if you are suppose to stay away and be light on your toes, bouncing around. So while these are definitely different martial art, they are not mixable.
Let's try another composition. Muay Thai and BJJ. A popular concoction. There are punches, elbows, knees, kicks, grabs, throws, takendowns, holds, joint locks, and chokes/strngulations all with some groundwork! This is a great mix. But, each one of those can takes years to master. So in order to gain proficeincy it is best to take a little from each, extend the time of training to master longer, but shorten the combined time for proficiency. We end up with a limited number of joint longs, escapes, strikes, and movement (footwork/groundwork).
A friend of mine suggested: (Due to the limited number of arts and those which are "mixable") MMA is nothing more than a title for an introductory course of simple locks, groundwork, and some kicking and punching. I can't disagree too much. This really eliminates the "MMA" aspect to MMA.
But perhaps we should reconsider what art arts. The Traditional art of Karate considers striking, joint-locks, throws, breathing, meditation, breaking, weapons (each one individually), forms, and sparring, all their own distinct art form
If we think of MMA broadly, it is a shame we don't treat the old MMA with the same respect.
I train MMA. I train Karate.
Train True. Train Hard.